THE RATS ARE BACK.
Eighteen rounds, a three-week finals series, and a grand final for the ages. The 2025 Shute Shield had it all - shocks, try-fests, country round classics, and a champion eight years in the making. Here's how it all unfolded.
2025 AWARDS
Ken Catchpole Medal - Player of the Year
Wes Thomas - Warringah
David Brockhoff Medal - Coach of the Year
Ben Batger - Eastern Suburbs
Roscoe Fay Trophy - Top Points Scorer
Coby Miln - Warringah
Top Try Scorer
Lachlan Shelley - Eastwood
Rookie of the Year
Marshall Le Maitre - Northern Suburbs
ES Marks Memorial Shield - Minor Premiers
Eastern Suburbs
ROUNDS 1-3
Wildfires Shock Warringah, Easts Flex Early Muscle, Souths Stun Manly
Round 1: Eastern Suburbs 45-10 Souths | Hunter 36-27 Warringah | Gordon 39-30 Two Blues | Eastwood 39-36 Randwick | Uni 59-26 West Harbour | Norths 41-38 Manly
Round 2: Easts 15-12 Hunter | Warringah 52-0 West Harbour | Uni 43-42 Randwick | Gordon 49-36 Norths | Eastwood 80-17 Souths | Parramatta 27-19 Manly
Round 3: Easts 27-16 Norths | Hunter 35-34 Eastwood | Randwick 64-24 Parramatta | Souths 40-33 Manly | Gordon 29-17 West Harbour | Warringah 46-17 Uni
The Shute Shield returned with a bang. Easts made a statement at Forshaw Rugby Park, Otto Serfontein surfing his way in for first points as the reigning champs' offloading game proved too hot for a Souths side still finding their feet. Cooper Whiteside solid off the tee, the Beasties looking every bit like defending champions.
But the game of round one was up the highway. Hunter hosted Warringah and sent shockwaves through the competition - Donny Freeman's mullet leading the charge upfront, Frankie Nowell finishing clinically out wide, and Sitiveni Vaihai dominant with ball in hand. The trip to Newcastle was already looking dangerous.
Round two delivered two of the moments of the season. Cooper Whiteside's 48-metre penalty from 16 in from touch sealed a 15-12 grinder for Easts against Hunter - not pretty, but the champions showed they could dogfight. Then at Uni Oval, the Students came back from 28-0 down after 13 minutes to beat Randwick 43-42, Nathanial Panozzo crashing over in the corner in the dying minutes. Absolute scenes. Eastwood, meanwhile, ran 80 points on Souths - a full-blown clinic with Tane Edmed pulling the strings.
Round three and the upsets kept coming. Souths stunning Manly 40-33 was the shock of the round - Mark Belaski running hot at ten, Damien Faiane's footwork a nightmare for the Marlins. Hunter then edged Eastwood 35-34 in a game the Woodies dominated for large chunks - until Ueta Tufuga, playing at 12, bludgeoned his way to two destructive tries in the final 20. Newcastle was becoming a fortress.
ROUNDS 4-6
Anzac Day, Cowra Classic and the Rats Finding Their Stride
Round 4: Warringah 44-8 Manly | Hunter 34-21 Souths | Norths 48-45 Eastwood | Two Blues 36-23 West Harbour | Randwick 34-19 Easts | Uni 31-19 Gordon
Round 5: Easts 66-5 Manly | Gordon 33-33 Eastwood | Hunter 48-34 Uni | Norths 33-17 Souths | Warringah 48-47 Two Blues | West Harbour 28-31 Randwick
Round 6: Eastwood 73-29 West Harbour | Gordon 29-19 Manly | Norths 34-19 Randwick | Souths 10-52 Warringah | Uni 36-40 Easts | Two Blues 17-36 Hunter
Anzac Day delivered the Battle of the Beaches - Warringah blowing Manly away 44-8 - and Cowra delivered one of the matches of the season. Norths versus Eastwood went completely off the rails: sin bins, a penalty try, both kickers going seven from seven, and the bald eagle James Margan dragged over by a ten-man Norths maul after the bell. 48-45. Country round magic.
Round five saw Darby Lancaster help himself to five tries as Easts ran 66 on Manly - one of the individual performances of the year. Rounds five and six confirmed the top sides were hitting top gear, with Warringah running riot against Souths 52-10 and Eastwood putting 73 on West Harbour. The competition was taking shape.
ROUNDS 7-10
Someone Stop the Wildfires - Minogue Magic and Saumaki Storm
Round 7: Eastwood 29-26 Manly | Hunter 40-20 Norths | Randwick 49-21 Souths | Uni 36-39 Two Blues | Warringah 18-8 Gordon | West Harbour 12-55 Easts
Round 8: Easts 32-31 Warringah | Gordon 26-10 Souths | Norths 32-30 Uni | Randwick 26-31 Manly | West Harbour 35-47 Hunter | Two Blues 45-48 Eastwood
Round 9: Easts 28-26 Gordon | Eastwood 32-36 Uni | Manly 31-24 Hunter | Souths 26-31 West Harbour | Warringah 47-19 Norths | Two Blues 27-14 Randwick
Round 10: Eastwood 24-26 Easts | Manly 33-15 Souths | Hunter 6-31 Gordon | Norths 29-24 Two Blues | Randwick 33-31 Warringah | Uni 38-19 West Harbour
Hunter continued to be the story of the season. Round after round, Newcastle was a graveyard of reputations. Their forward pack, with Freeman leading the charge, was the most physically imposing unit in the competition. The Wildfires' 40-20 demolition of Norths in round seven was a statement - this was no fluke side.
Matt Minogue was the player of this stretch of the season - the Norths flyhalf combining ice-cold kicking with composure well beyond his years. Round eight saw one of the tight finishes of the year - Easts holding off Warringah 32-31 in a top-of-table classic. The Two Blues' Hosea Saumaki was also making a case for the highlights reel every week - a human wrecking ball who somehow also had footwork.
Round nine produced a genuine surprise with Manly beating Hunter 31-24, snapping the Wildfires' home fortress record, and the Two Blues pipping Randwick 39-36 in a thriller. Round ten saw Gordon hand Hunter a heavy 31-6 defeat in Newcastle - a reminder that inconsistency could cost the Wildfires when it mattered most.
ROUNDS 11-15
The Ladder Takes Shape - Finals Race Heats Up
Round 11: Gordon 41-31 Uni | Hunter 27-26 Randwick | Norths 31-38 Easts | Souths 17-29 Eastwood | West Harbour 24-38 Manly | Two Blues 29-44 Warringah
Round 12: Easts 31-24 Randwick | Hunter 31-32 Two Blues | Norths 18-22 Gordon | Uni 58-22 Souths | Warringah 30-21 Manly | West Harbour 33-53 Eastwood
Round 13: Easts 47-10 Souths | Eastwood 57-31 Gordon | Manly 45-37 Two Blues | Norths 61-19 West Harbour | Randwick 40-17 Uni | Warringah 26-21 Hunter
Round 14: Eastwood 12-22 Hunter | Gordon 22-32 Warringah | Manly 33-36 Easts | Souths 24-33 Randwick | Uni 24-35 Norths | Two Blues 35-30 West Harbour
Round 15: Easts 54-40 Two Blues | Hunter 54-26 Souths | Norths 45-35 Eastwood | Randwick 34-27 Gordon | West Harbour 16-44 Warringah | Uni 45-24 Manly
The back half of the regular season delivered exactly what you want from a competition this good - late drama, dazzling doubles, naughty boys collecting yellow cards, and blowouts keeping the points differential conversations alive.
Lachlan Shelley confirmed himself as the competition's premier try scorer. Week in, week out, the Eastwood winger found a way. Give him a sniff of space and he'd do the rest - often creating it himself. Eastwood's 57-31 demolition of Gordon in round 13 and 53-33 over West Harbour in round 12 showed the Woodies had genuine firepower.
Easts were locking down the minor premiership - the 47-10 hammering of Souths in round 13 and Manly's scalp in round 14 keeping them firmly on top. Ben Batger's coaching drawing deserved praise - his Beasties structured, physical, and capable of scoring from anywhere.
Warringah, meanwhile, just kept winning. The 44-16 thumping of West Harbour in round 15 and Gordon scalp in round 14 showed the Rats had the depth to go all the way. Wes Thomas was everywhere. Miln automatic off the tee. The X-factor was there.
ROUNDS 16-18
Finals Locked In, Last Rites Written
Round 16: Easts 45-34 Warringah | Eastwood 49-29 Manly | Hunter 43-21 West Harbour | Norths 32-28 Randwick | Souths 40-33 Gordon | Two Blues 28-31 Uni
Round 17: Easts 42-15 Uni | Gordon 24-22 Hunter | Manly 5-20 Randwick | Warringah 32-12 Eastwood | West Harbour 32-38 Souths | Two Blues 19-29 Norths
Round 18: Gordon 35-17 Easts | Manly 15-13 West Harbour | Norths 36-33 Warringah | Randwick 31-7 Hunter | Souths 43-41 Two Blues | Uni 21-42 Eastwood
The final three rounds tidied up the finals picture - and delivered some genuine last-round drama. Easts were pipped by Gordon 35-17 in round 18 but had already sewn up the minor premiership. Warringah lost to Norths 36-33 in a thriller but had done enough to secure their finals berth. Hunter's 31-7 loss to Randwick in the final round raised some eyebrows heading into finals week.
By the time the final siren sounded, the picture was set. Easts as minor premiers. Warringah, Hunter, Norths, and Eastwood all in the mix. It was set up beautifully.
Preliminary finals
QUALIFIERS: Easts 40-19 Randwick | Norths 43-26 Eastwood | Warringah 43-27 Hunter
SEMI FINALS: Easts 33-19 Eastwood | Warringah 38-22 Norths
Warringah ended Hunter's maiden Shute Shield dream in a gripping qualifier, 43-27. The Wildfires had been the competition's great story all season, but the Rats found the answer. Miln's accuracy off the tee proved decisive. The Wildfire season was over. What a campaign it was.
Easts dispatched Randwick comfortably and then saw off Eastwood 33-19 in the semi to punch their ticket to the grand final, with Michael Icely and Darby Lancaster both crossing. Norths went all the way to the semi-final before Warringah ran away 38-22, Ivan Fepuleai and Charlie McKill sealing it late.
THE. BIG. ONE.
Warringah 37-24 Eastern Suburbs
Leichhardt Oval. Warringah versus the defending champions. Easts drew first blood but the Rats responded through Chlayton Frans and Keelan Whitman before half-time, with Coby Miln - as reliable as ever - slotting the extras. The second half was an arm-wrestle: Easts clawed it back to three with 10 to play through Archer Gavin, but Frans iced it with his second, streaking away against the run of play to put the result beyond doubt.
37-24 to the Rats. Eight years between premierships. Frans with two tries. Miln automatic all season and in the grand final. Wes Thomas: Ken Catchpole Medal, every bit deserving of it. The Rat Army poured onto Leichhardt and the rest is history.